accidents are hard, friends

Share
accidents are hard, friends

No doubt about it, Fiona was beloved.

Fiona was born in early 2017, catching the world's attention when she arrived six weeks prematurely at just 29 pounds — roughly half the previous lowest recorded birth weight for a hippo. She was about the size of a football, with little body fat, tiny veins and clearly underdeveloped lungs. Staff at the Cincinnati Zoo, along with Cincinnati Children's Hospital, worked around the clock, providing all sorts of creative care. They had to help her breathe. Help her walk. Essentially, help her live. And live, she did.

With social media giving us a window into a miracle we might otherwise have missed, Fiona beat the unprecedented odds, becoming the smallest premature hippo known to survive in human care. She became an international symbol of perseverance. She wasn't just a hippo at a zoo. Millions of us fell in love with her.

Unfortunately, last Thursday, at only nine years old (the average lifespan of a common hippo is 40-50 years), Fiona passed away. And the circumstances make it harder.

Fiona died following what appears to have been a terribly unfortunate accident. A child visiting the zoo tossed a hat into the air — maybe multiple times. It hit a ceiling fan, which flung it through a small opening into the hippo enclosure. Fiona swallowed the hat, which became lodged in her intestine. Surgery wasn't an option given her anatomy and size. Staff tried desperately, but they couldn't save her. How very sad indeed.

So now what? How do we deal with accidents? After all, consequences are a part (and I would suggest a necessary part) of life.

Many have demanded consequences — accountability, fines or even criminal charges — against the child or the child's parents.

Others have stopped short of demanding criminal charges, but have wisely pointed out that we live in a society that often minimizes consequences for damaging behavior, especially when it's unintentional. It's as if, "Because I didn't intend to hurt someone (even though I did), I'm not responsible for the result."

That doesn't make sense either.

Intent matters. But so does the outcome. Just because something was accidental doesn't mean there are no consequences. Sometimes the consequences are enormous, even when the intent was never there.

I understand the anger. Anger is often part of grief. People are grieving Fiona's death. They loved her, watched her grow up and celebrated her against-the-odds beginning. Now they have to deal with an ending that feels entirely unfair.

In their anger, some have suggested this was the result of "bad parenting." That doesn't seem right either. Is a parent supposed to control every behavioral impulse of a child? At some point, that feels less like accountability and more like our impulse to find someone to blame when something awful happens.

Accidents are hard, friends.

We want to hold someone responsible. Understandably. We want an answer, someone to answer to, and some consequence that might make the whole thing feel a little less senseless. But sometimes, there isn't a simple answer.

The child may not have intended any harm. The parents may not have anticipated what would happen. And yet a beloved animal is dead. We can’t dismiss that simply because it was an accident.

The child, too, will have to live with knowing what happened. I suspect that will be a difficult burden to carry. It is also a consequence, even if not one imposed by a court or a fine.

But is it enough? Should there be something more? 

That's where I think we need to be careful.

Consequences should be just, but determining justice isn't always easy, especially when we're grieving or angry. In fact, those are probably the moments when we are least equipped to make such a determination.

We can acknowledge the seriousness of what happened without assuming the worst about the people involved. We can believe in accountability without rushing to punishment. And we can be heartbroken over our beloved Fiona without letting our heartbreak dictate what justice should actually look like.

Soberly…

AR